Orthodox Unity ~ Resources

Here are some resources on Orthodox Unity. I will update this page as more resources become available.

Chambesy Documents

Unraveling Chambesy – Administrative Unity In Our Time
Ancient Faith Radio Special Presentation

Chalcedon Canon 28: Yesterday and Today

Fr. Ted Bobosh has a discussion on his blog about this topic here are the links:
Considering Chambesy: the Mother Churches
Considering Chambesy: The Diaspora
Considering Chambesy: The Issues
Considering Chambesy: The Decisions
Considering Chambesy: The Articles Governing the Assemblies
Considering Chambesy: The Chairmanship of the Ecumenical Patriarch

Orthodox Unity ~ Part 2

Let me start by saying I am not a canonist and have not studied canon law. But then again the Orthodox Church does not have canon law in the same way the Roman Church does. We have canons but not in the same sense as the Roman Church therefore we do not have canon lawyers but people who have studied patristics and the Church Councils.

With that said in this article we will look at the concept of Autocephaly. Autocephaly is simply self ruled in the sense that the head of the Church does not report to anyone else. They elect their own bishops and deal with internal church matters. In the US the OCA is the only church that meets this definition. The question is not whether a church is or is not but how it gains this status. And who has the right to declare it.

The question has been who has the authority to declare a church autocephalous? Does the mother church have this authority or is it reserved to the Ecumenical Patriarch? Well the answer to that question depends on who you talk too. The way it was described to me was that the mother church grants it and the others have to recognize it. The Church of Russia granted the then Metropolia Autocephaly in the 70’s but it has not been recognized by the others. Yes recognized as a canonical church with valid orders and sacraments but not independent.

To get the answer we turn to Canon 28 of the Council of Chalcedon:

Following in every detail the decrees of the holy fathers, and taking cognizance of the canon just read of the 150 bishops dearly beloved of God who gathered under Theodosius the Great, emperor of pious memory, in the imperial city of Constantinople, New Rome, we ourselves have also decreed and voted the same things concerning the prerogatives of the most holy Church of the same Constantinople, New Rome. For the fathers rightly acknowledged [apodedōkasi] the prerogatives of the throne of the Elder Rome because it was the Imperial City, and moved by the same consideration the 150 bishops beloved of God awarded [apeneiman] the same prerogatives to the most holy throne of the New Rome, rightly judging that the city which is honored by the imperial authority and the senate and enjoys the same [civil] prerogatives as the imperial city of the Elder Rome, should also be magnified in ecclesiastical matters as she is, being second after [deuteran met’ekeinēn] her.

Consequently [kai hōste], the metropolitans – and they alone – of the dioceses of Pontus, Asia and Thrace, as well as the bishops of the aforementioned dioceses who are among the barbarians, shall be ordained by the aforementioned most holy throne of the most holy Church of Constantinople. Each metropolitan of the aforementioned dioceses, along with his fellow-bishops of the province, ordains the bishops of the province, as has been provided for in the canons; but the metropolitans of the aforementioned dioceses, as has been stated, shall be ordained by the archbishop of Constantinople, after proper elections have been made according to custom and have been reported to him.

Okay all clear now? I am guessing no. As I understand this Canon and the understanding of the EP is the the EP designates the Autocephaly. This is the disagreement between everyone at the moment. Very confusing I know but it all has to do with gets to do what. The EP is the first among equals but what that means no one really knows. What power does the EP actually have?

As I mentioned in the last post SCOBA has called for an Episcopal Assembly based on the statement from Chambsey. The Exarch of the EP will preside as President or Chairman of this assembly based on the Dyptics or the order of Churches. Some see this as a way for the EP to gain control of the church in the US. Leaving Oliver Stone on the sidelines for a moment, this is Church order and how it is done. I am holding out hope that great things will happen to Holy Orthodoxy in this Country but it will take time.

The Indispensable Church

I will admit I like to read lots of blogs on various topics. Some of my favorite revolve around church growth and other such church topics. I am for example re-reading Rick Warren’s book The Purpose Driven Church. I believe that there are many things we can learn from each other weather we agree or not on doctrinal or practice of our faith. No idea should be discounted just because it is not an “orthodox” idea. We are all in this together and need to support each other.

Recently Trinity College in Connecticut released a new study called “American Nones: The Profile of the No Religion Population” Now it should come as no surprise to people involved in church work that less than 18% of the people in the US attend church on Sunday morning. Many things contribute to this and this is a phenomenon that has been taking place since the 1970’s so we should have been ready for it. I think, for the most part, that religion has become something that is not essential in people’s lives. How do we reverse this trend? Can we reverse this trend?

I have been reading a blog called “Confessions of a Small-Church Pastor” authored by Chuck Warnock. Chuck is a Baptist Pastor in Virginia and writes a blog for churches of no more than 300. Lot’s of great stuff and I think all of us that pastor these types of churches should be reading his blog and learning from each other. Well today he had a posting called “The Indispensable Church” In this post he asks the question, “How can church become indispensable to a community?” He claims we need to stop asking the question how can we get more people to come to church? and focus on the previous question.

I am sure that those of us who are involved in church work would love to pastor church of say 1,400 families, well not me anyway I think those churches are too big and should be broken up. I am looking for the church that lives the mission of Jesus Christ. The other question Pastor Chuck asks is, “If our church was to close tomorrow would anyone notice?”

I would like to think people would, and I am sure he means people other than the ones who attend the church. What are you doing as church to make yourself indispensable to the community?

Here at St. Michael’s we have begun a feeding program that we call the Community Meal. One night a month we provide a meal to anyone who wish to come for free. I usually do the cooking and people like Laura, John, Linda & Vic come and help serve the meal. It is great and we get about 40 people or so each month. Different menu each month and last month one of the local restaurants provided the meal. Does this make us indispensable, not yet but I hope we are working on it.

So that’s the question. Are we just providing liturgical services? This is important don’t get me wrong, but what are we doing to further the mission of the church as Jesus taught us. Feed the hungry, clothe the naked, visit the sick and those in prison. What are we doing?

Book Review ~ From Peanuts to the Press Box

From Peanuts to Pressbox
By Eli Gold
Hardcover: 272 pages
Publisher: Thomas Nelson (September 15, 2009)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1401604366
ISBN-13: 978-1401604363

I was drawn to this title as one who did a little stint in the broadcast world. Eli Gold tells the story of himself going from literally selling peanuts in the stands to entering the pressbox and covering sporting events for radio and TV.

This is a great inside view not only of the world of sports but the world of broadcasting. From riding on the bus with the minor league hockey teams to getting his first shot behind the microphone Eli Gold brings us into his life with all of the trials and tribulations that it takes to become a broadcaster.

He gives very practical advice to one who would like to enter this field. If you are interested in becoming a broadcaster, not just a sports broadcaster but any kind of broadcaster, he gives sage advice to all.

I received this book as part of the Thomas Nelson Publishers Blogger Book Review Program and therefore it was sent to me at no cost.

Orthodox Unity ~ Part 1

If you follow this blog then you know that this past weekend I attended our Deanery Meeting in Rochester, New York. The focus of the first part of the meeting was on Orthodox Unity. Much has been written around the Internet about this topic and I am going to add to that a little in a series of blog posts on this very topic.

Let me begin with the simple fact that this is a long and complicated process that from the outside looks very simple. I grew up in the Roman Church with her top down approach to all things church and that is simply not the case in the Orthodox Church. The ecclesiology of the Orthodox Church is very different but at the same time similar to that of the Church of Rome.

To try and keep things simple the Orthodox Church does not have a single head as does the Church of Rome. The Patriarch of Constantinople is considered the Spiritual Head of the Orthodox Church but in the spirit of collegiality he is Primus inter pares or first among equals. The Ecumenical Patriarch is not a Pope in the same sense as the Pope of Rome. From a very practical point of view the EP only has jurisdiction over the churches that come under his authority. Okay a circular argument I know. Where things get a little dicey is here in the US and Western Europe but that is for another day.

In the ancient of days there were four original patriarchates that were called autocephalous. They are Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem. We must add Rome to that list and actually Rome would take the first place in line. After those come the other churches in order of precedence: Russia Serbia Romania Bulgaria Georgia Cyprus Greece Poland Albania Czech Lands and Slovakia Orthodox Church if America. The OCA has a disputed Autocephaly and again that is another topic. An Autocephalous church is simply a church whose leader does not report if you will to someone above them. The Patriarchate of Romanian for example is an autocephalous church. Patriarch Daniel is the head of the Orthodox Church in Romania and if there was to be an organizational chart of the Christian Church in the world he would be on the same level as the Pope of Rome. The present holder of the office is His Beatitude Daniel, is the Archbishop of Bucharest, Metropolitan of Muntenia and Dobrodgea, locum tenens of the throne of Caesarea of Cappadocia, Patriarch of the Romanian Orthodox Church. With me so far?

The big question that needs to be answered is who gets to grant the status of Autocephaly? Is it left to the EP alone or can the Mother church grant it to her daughters? This is where things get confusing if they have not already done so.

Here in the United States we have 10 canonical Orthodox Churches each with their own structure and leadership. We also have what is called overlapping jurisdictions. For example in Boston there are two bishops with the title Bishop of Boston and that does not include the Catholic Archbishop of Boston. Now there also exists, and if you do a simple google search of the term Orthodox you will find several thousand so called “orthodox” churches in the US and other places. We are dealing with the canonical ones here.

A conference of all the patriarchates in the world was called at Chambésy Switzerland in June and some action was taken to resolve issues in what is being called the Diaspora or churches outside of the common Orthodox Lands. The document is short and can be read on the web page of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese and other places. The main thrust of this document is the calling of an Episcopal Assembly. At present there is an organization of ruling bishops in the US called the Standing Conference of Canonical Orthodox Bishops in America (SCOBA). The Membership of SCOBA at the present time is made up of the 10 ruling bishops from the 10 canonical jurisdictions. This new assembly will increase the membership to all of the Canonical Bishops in the USA and Canada. I am unsure of how many that will be. The idea is to start to work on administrative unity. There is a call for an Autocephalous American Orthodox Church and that may be a reality one day but for now we just need to work together. The interesting thing about this assembly is that each jurisdiction will have one vote. Each bishop will not vote but they will vote as a block. So am Archdiocese such as mine with two bishops will have the same vote as the OCA with man more than that. The assembly has been called for sometime in May of 2010.

In the next article I will focus a little more on this concept of Autocephaly and also on the canonical vs non canonical churches.

Rochester, New York

Day 2 here in Rochester has begun. Well I have had coffee anyway and I am up and at em that’s about all I can say.

Yesterday was a long day with the drive out here from the Village but once we got here things were in full swing. There are about 50 of us from all over the Eastern Deanery of the Romanian Archdiocese and the focus of yesterday’s events was Unity of the Orthodox in America. More specifically Unity among the Romanian Orthodox in America. We talked for a long time about things that have been put in place and things that will be coming in the future. A very interesting and prayerful conversation. I am looking forward to the future.

After the Unction service the priests met with the Archbishop to talk about some issues in the deanery and the conversation went to the concept of Economia. Economia is the pastoral practice of doing things for pastor sake. Like letting someone sit during confession even though the typicon says they should stand. More about that in another post. But it was a great albeit long discussion.

Today the focus will be on Stewardship and the more mundane rules and regulations and such. We will also have a presentation on St. Basil the Great as we are celebrating the year of St. Basil. After the that, the long journey home begins. Please continue to pray for all of us who are gathered here engaged in God’s work and please pray for a safe journey home.

Impossible Broccoli Pie

This recipe comes from the book, Scottish Family Cookbook and is from Sue Bean. I made this the other day for breakfast and it is GREAT! It would be good for Sunday brunch or some other family breakfast.

2 pkgs (10 oz. each) frozen chopped broccoli
3 c. shredded cheddar cheese
2/3 c. chopped onion
1 1/3 c. milk
3 eggs
3/4 c. buttermilk baking mix
3/4 tsp. salt
1/4 tsp pepper

Heat oven to 400 degrees. Grease pie plate, 10 x 1 1;2 inches. Rinse broccoli under running cold water to thaw; drain thoroughly. In the pie plate, mix broccoli, 2 cups of the cheese and the onion. Beat milk, eggs, baking mix, salt and pepper until smooth, 15 seconds in a blender on high, or 1 minute with a hand beater. Pour into the pie plate. Bake for 25 to 35 minutes, until knife inserted in center comes out clean. Top with remaining cheese. Bake until cheese is melted, 1-2 minutes longer. Let stand 5 minutes. Garnish with tomato slices if desired. 6 servings.

Off Again

Well I am off again on yet another trip. This time I am heading to Rochester, New York for a meeting of the Eastern Deanery of the Romanian Archdiocese.

Several years ago we changed the way we govern things here in the US. My Archdiocese used to gather each year in what we call the Congress. The Congress is the Legislative body of the Archdiocese. We would gather in a different place, usually a church celebrating a big anniversary or the last few years we have been meeting at the Cathedral in Chicago. We would hear a variety of reports and have meetings on various topics. A few years back we changed all of this and now the Congress meets every other year and the year in between we have a deanery gathering.

So this is the time for the gathering. We are heading to Holy Trinity Orthodox Church in Rochester and will have a series of meetings with the Archbishop and share fellowship with others from the deanery. The deanery is rather large and covers all of the east coast. not sure how many are making the journey but it should be a good, albeit, fast weekend as we are back in the church on Sunday.

Blogging will be light but you can always follow me on Twitter if you like.

Orthodox Christian Laity Praises SCOBA Decision

NEW YORK, Oct. 1 /Christian Newswire/ — Orthodox Christian Laity expressed strong support for the unanimous decision taken September 25, 2009, by the Standing Conference of Canonical Orthodox Bishops in the Americas (SCOBA) to hold a meeting next year on Orthodox unity, describing it as “another major step in the process leading to serious discussion about the future of Orthodoxy in America and the role of unity in that future.”

Peter Petkas, OCL president, praised SCOBA Chairman, Archbishop Demetrios and his fellow hierarchs for “their visionary and swift response to the Pan-Orthodox call for church unity issued last October in Istanbul and again this June in Chambesy, Switzerland. All serious Orthodox Christians are most grateful and encouraged by SCOBA’s decisive leadership in moving this process forward.”

“We realize that this meeting, scheduled Post-Pentecost Week of 2010, is just the beginning of a long journey toward closer cooperation and unity among Orthodox in America, but we are most heartened that our spiritual leaders are pointing us in the right direction,” Mr. Petkas continued.
George Matsoukas, OCL Executive Director, voiced “the hope that in the months ahead, Orthodox Christians, inspired by SCOBA’s leadership, would begin their own discussions about the possibilities and potential that unity holds for our Church and her life in America. In that respect, OCL is committed to helping the unity effort; and, on October 29-31 at Antiochian Village, Ligonier, PA, is hosting a conversation with the hierarchy, including Metropolitan Jonah as keynoter, other hierarchs, clergy and laity on ‘The Road to Unity — From Vision to Action’ which directly relates to the recent developments within the Church.”

The SCOBA decision is in accord with a decision authorized by the Fourth Pre-Conciliar Pan-Orthodox Conference, convened by Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew in coordination with the 14 Old World Patriarchs at Chambesy on June 6-13, for the convening of “Episcopal Assemblies” to address the status of Orthodoxy outside the borders of the Autocephalous Churches.

Orthodox Christian Laity, an independent movement established in 1987, has been a leading and consistent advocate for Orthodox unity in North America and for the laity’s full participation in Church life; and in that spirit, anticipates that all members of the Church will fully engage in the process of leading to a unified North American Church.

You can register online for the OCL Conference at www.ocl.org/roadtounity. Contact George Matsoukas, Executive Director, at 877-585-0245. Visit www.ocl.org or www.orthodoxnews.org.

Yesterday

What a glorious day yesterday was! The weather was just amazing and fall is indeed here in New England and I am happy as a clam.

Yesterday was also our Parish Golf Tournament, fondly named after on of our long time parishioners that fell asleep in the Lord a year ago. Sandra, his wife, was present at the meal in the hall after and she was just telling everyone how proud George would be because of all of this. I agree with one exception George IS proud of all that has gone on in his name.

Yesterday was also a great because I got spend time with my three brothers and one of my nephews. Since my ordination and move to the Village I do not get to see my brothers that often. Although we live close, about and hour away, most of the time that they are available is on weekends, and well I work weekends! So we do not get to see each other that often. Sure holidays and what not but not as often as we used too. But yesterday was special and I will treasure yesterday for a long time. Boy did we have fun oh yea we also played a little golf, very little mind you. Good thing this was a best ball tournament or I would still be on the course. I think I am the only priest that does not play golf. I do enjoy it an maybe I will start playing more in the spring.

Well yesterday was a long day but a good day, a fun day. Lots of memories. Thanks to my brothers and nephew for making the effort to come out it was great to hang with them again. Let’s do it again soon!

error: Content is protected !!