For some time now I have been thinking about this torture thing that everyone is talking about. How does this effect all of us and should we be concerned about it. Yesterday I posted a poll for my daily radio show about waterboarding. The results were not surprising to me but a little disturbing none the less. A vast majority of the respondents believe that it is not torture to waterboard someone.
So I came across this article on the First Things Blog by Russell E. Saltzman and he has helped my clarify my thinking on this position. Right in the center of the article the author makes this statement:
I’ve been trying, like many Americas, to think this thing through. There is the altogether practical question: Did torture help us? Did it make America safer? Was the information really good, helpful, in thwarting terrorists? Did it actually in fact spoil pending plots? Frankly, the evidence is mixed.
But I really don’t care. Whether torture “worked” or not as an interrogative tactic is far from the main question. I’m a pastor. I think as a pastor, which is to say as a parish theologian. I don’t care if these guys shrieked like little girls on the playground and blubbered out plots for everything from the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre to knocking over Bagdad candy stores as juvenile delinquents. Torture is morally wrong. It is morally wrong, theologically speaking, because it is an attack upon the imago Dei, upon the image of God inherent to every human life.
Now, I’m not so dumb or so liberal that I can’t understand and remember and share the anger the September 11 attack produced in America, nor was I the least bit hesitant in supporting the studied determination of making sure that nothing like it ever happens again. But if there is anyone suggesting the American homeland is safer today for having abandoned the ordinary principles of humane treatment for prisoners in American custody, then he’s a moral midget. Torture is not what Americans do. Not if we still have some lingering respect for the rights with which God endows humanity.
The important phrase in this entire discussion is the image of God. That is what it all boils down too. As Christians we cannot stand for anything that diminishes the image of God in one of his creations. No matter who, or what that person is we cannot allow this to happen. Any torture is a moral outrage and we need to stand up for those who cannot stand up for themselves.
This will take many hours of thought and prayer and discussion but it is a discussion that we need to have.